Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
Forgive...and Remember

Sermon:
March 2nd, 2008
Morning Services

Scripture:
Matthew 18:23-35

Some years ago, I saw an ad from a British newspaper announcing the “Postal Forgiveness Service.” It comes from Father Alfred Rawlins, vicar of St. Mary in the Fields, Newcastle on Tyne. It shows a picture of the consoling priest himself with clerical collar, proper gray hair and a gentle smile. The headline announces:  

Make Your Peace With God…For as Little as 10 Pounds 

And the paragraph reads: 

Now and then we all stray from the path of righteousness, and in today’s busy world, finding time to go to confession is none too easy. How much easier it would be to get forgiveness at a time which suits you. Well now, with the new Postal Forgiveness Service brought to you by Father Alfred Rawlins, you can be forgiven of your trespasses from the comfort of your own home. Simply fill out the coupon below and send it in with cheque or postal money order to Father Rawlins.   

Then the clip-off coupon with easy-to-check boxes: 

Father, forgive me, for I have sinned. I have committed the following sins:

Profanity           1 pound

Falsehood        10 pounds

Adultery           15 pounds

Theft                20 pounds 

And finally, this note at the bottom:  

Please allow 28 days for forgiveness.  

Wouldn’t it be nice if it was that easy to make our peace with God and with one another?
 

1.  Father, forgive us our sins. 

My first appointment in 1972 was to three small churches in rural western Pennsylvania—Hawthorn, Oak Ridge and Mt. Zion. It was only four years after the merger of the Evangelical United Brethren and the Methodist Church. Hawthorn and Mt. Zion were former EUB and Oak Ridge was former Methodist. At Hawthorn and Mt. Zion, when we prayed the Lord’s Prayer we followed the EUB tradition, praying, “Forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.” But at Hawthorn we used the Methodist version: “Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us.”  

Running between three services in the three churches on Sunday morning, then one Sunday night service at Hawthorn and three mid-week prayer meetings, I always had to remember where I was in order to lead the prayer. When it came to combined services, I figured it was every man for himself, and I just got real quiet so as not to appear to be taking sides.  

Even now, forty years after the merger, we still have both versions in our hymnal, plus the newer version which uses the word “sins” instead of either debts or trespasses.  

But whether you say debts, trespasses or sins, the starting point is the acknowledgment of our own need of mercy, forgiveness and grace.  

Some years ago, therapist and theologian Carl Menninger wrote a book which raised the question: Whatever Became of Sin? Of course, if you asked that question today, you might answer that sin has become the stuff of entertainment—think the Spears family or Jerry Springer—flaunting our indiscretions for all to see. Or reflect on the Oscar movies with themes like bitter revenge, cold-blooded murder, sexual indiscretions and corrupt business practices. But personal sin? Acknowledging my own shortcomings, my own need for forgiveness and redemption, confession and pardon? Well, that’s something else altogether. Yet the path to new life begins when I realize my own need of grace, my own sin.  

The story is told of the proud and brash, but not very becoming, Oliver Cromwell, who one day was sitting for a personal portrait to be painted. In the midst of it, in all of his arrogance, he said to the artist, “Well, my good man, I hope you can do me justice.” It is said that the artist responded, “It’s not justice you need, it’s mercy.” And in the broad light of God’s word, so do we.          

“All we like sheep have gone astray.”

“We have all fallen short of the glory of God.”  

We all stand in need of God’s grace. Our journey toward wholeness begins with the simple prayer: “Forgive us our sins.”  

And that is where today’s parable begins.           

It begins with the servant’s realization of his need of mercy. His master confronts him with this incredible debt which would have sounded totally absurd to Jesus’ hearers—10,000 talents! For the common laborer, that would be equal to about fifteen years worth of wages. It is more than the total budget of a typical province in that time. King Herod himself collected the inordinate sum of 1,000 talents per year in taxes to support his lavish lifestyle, and Jesus says what this man owed was more than ten times Herod’s annual spending. The servant first offers to pay, which of course is completely impossible. Then, acknowledging his total inability to save himself, he pleads for mercy. 

Author Keith Miller tells the story on himself. He was raised a northern city boy in Chicago and had never been south of the Mason Dixon Line until he went to basic training at Ft. Benning,  Georgia. On the first day, he came down for breakfast in the mess hall, picked up his tray, and saw this gooey white stuff in the serving line which he thought looked for all the world like cream of wheat. So he dished up a big bowl of it and put milk and sugar on top. Well, the Georgia farm boy across the table from him started to laugh and said, “Whatcha doin’ to them grits, putting milk and sugar on them? Is that how you eat grits?” Unwilling to be embarrassed, he responded, “You bet! This is how we eat ’em in Chicago!” And the Georgia good old boy watched in amazement as he ate them.  

The next morning when he sat down for breakfast, the same Georgia soldier was right across from him, and of course, he had to do the same thing—another bowl of grits with milk and sugar.  He says, “Unwilling to admit I had made a mistake, I somehow managed to eat the mess again.” 

His conclusion: “We would rather go to hell maintaining our innocence than to say, ‘I was wrong.’” (Edge of Adventure, page 14) 

All we like sheep have gone astray. All have fallen short of the glory of God.  

Father, forgive us our trespasses.

Father, forgive us our debts.

Father, forgive us our sins… 

2.  “...as we forgive those who have sinned against us.” 

Ouch. Now, as the old southern Baptist lady used to say, “He done stopped preachin’ and started meddlin’.” When we acknowledge our need of mercy, when we have experienced God’s amazing grace, when forgiveness comes our way, the path leads in only one direction. For the servant in the parable, it leads to his neighbor.  

Now again, to get the real punch of the story, you have to realize the ridiculous contrast Jesus offers. Here is a man who has just been forgiven of a debt which is equal to fifteen years of wages—10,000 talents—ten times greater than Herod’s annual expenditures. And what happens?  He immediately encounters a neighbor who owes him not even one talent, just a few denarii, about ten bucks! In the light of what he has just experienced, what does he do? He grabs him by the neck and demands payment. And when the poor man begs forgiveness, he has him thrown in jail.  

Jesus’ point is so simple, so obvious. When I acknowledge my own need of forgiveness, when I realize the great debt Christ has paid, when I am overwhelmed by God’s amazing grace for me, I am called to do the same, called to the path of forgiveness.  

At this point it’s important to remember the context of his parable. Peter has just asked Jesus the 64,000 dollar question: “Lord, how often shall we forgive? As many as seven times?” You see, Jewish law required three times, so Peter was offering more than twice what the law required.  He was thinking of himself as generous, maybe even a bit smug, a little self-righteous, thinking he was being so merciful. And Jesus replied, “I do not say seven times, but seventy times seven.”   

Which is to say, it’s not about keeping count, it’s about mercy. It’s not about keeping score, it’s about grace.  

Unlimited, undeserved, unearned, immeasurable, immense, overwhelming grace. And in the prayer we pray every week, Jesus goes so far as to dare us to pray: “Father, forgive me my sins, even as I forgive those who have sinned against me.” 

The pipeline of grace flows from God to me to others. And if you plug up the pipeline at one end, it stops flowing at the other.  

God calls us to forgive.  

Now I would never suggest the path is easy, quick or simple. Forgiveness is seldom linear or fast or even complete. Forgiveness is not the same as legal pardon. There is also the matter of justice, recompense and restitution. Forgiveness does not guarantee reconciliation. One person can forgive but it takes two to reconcile, and sometimes that simply can’t happen. But the path to wholeness includes the step of forgiveness. Bishop Tutu is right. Not only for the nation of South Africa, but for all of us there is “no future without forgiveness.”   

I’ll share my own witness at this point. It involves an uncle who was a drain on the family for most of his life. He cheated on his numerous wives, deserted his children, stole from his brothers, and embarrassed my grandfather right in front of Gramps’ pastor. The last time I saw him for almost twenty years was literally over my dad’s deathbed when we had a pretty bitter exchange. I saw him one more time at another uncle’s funeral, when we were at least polite with each other. When I heard of his death, it didn’t really bring relief, but it felt like the end of a sad saga in our family.   

For almost three decades now, I have dealt with Uncle Earl as a part of my life and my story and I have struggled to forgive. I can’t say it’s complete. In fact, even to tell the story dredges up my own anger and resentment. But I know that for the sake of my own soul and sanity, the path leads through forgiveness. We never reconciled in life, and of course, with his death there is no option for that. But I know that if I am to be whole, if I am to find my own sense of well-being, I must continually seek to forgive. Harboring resentment only blocks the flow of God’s mercy and forgiveness in my life. And in the end, it only hurts me. 

Two things have been helpful to me. The first is to remember what my brother said after Uncle Earl’s death: “In the resurrection, all is healed and all will be well, and the circle will be unbroken by and by.” And I pray that is true.  

The second is to remember how much God has already forgiven me. And if God has been so merciful with me, then what else can I do but seek to forgive?    

3.  Father, forgive us our sins, even as we forgive those who sin against us…and help us to remember.  

Rev. Laurie Haller reminds us that: 

Forgiveness requires remembering, not forgetting. The past has a way of returning and haunting us unless we remember it and acknowledge it. Forgiveness doesn’t mean forgetting, but it does mean letting go of the hold the past has on us.

(Rev. Laurie Haller, “Forgiveness: What’s the Big Deal?”

FUMC Grand Rapids, March 5, 2006) 

And of course, that’s what I am striving to do with Uncle Earl. I will never forget the past, but I am striving to be free of the hold the past has on me, remembering the grace and forgiveness I have already received from God.  

In working on this sermon, I came across an old article from Time Magazine in 1974, just after President Gerald Ford’s pardon of Richard Nixon. After the way he had abused the office and the nation, most of us were none too sympathetic toward Nixon. And few of us supported Ford’s decision, especially since Nixon never repented, never acknowledged his need of forgiveness.   

But in this Time essay, Mayo Mohs says: 

There is a difference between pardon and amnesty. Amnesty means to forget. Pardon presumes guilt, but it represents the desire to forgive. 

And his concluding paragraph says: 

Each of us is to a degree lost, tied to the rest of humanity and to God by fragile strands of grace, strands that fray and break. Forgiveness is a favor that we may sometimes be in a position to grant, but more important, it is one that we will always need. (Time Magazine, Sept. 23, 1974) 

Father, forgive us our sins, as we forgive those who sin against us. 

Freely, freely you have received;

Freely, freely give.


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |