Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
Seeing the Unseen

Sermon:
December 16th, 2007
Morning Services

Scripture:
Luke 1:14-38

Last week, the story of Zachariah and Elizabeth invited us to “expect the unexpected.”  This week, Mary’s tale invites us to “see the unseen.” It’s a familiar story of Mary and the vision: 

·        a young maiden and a heavenly mystery

·        an unexpected angel and an overpowering annunciation

·        an expectant mother and a joyous Magnificat

·        a humble servant of the Lord, willing to become the blessed mother dressed in royal blue with a holy halo hovering over her humbly bowed head  

But that’s not where the story begins. And it’s not just Mary’s story—it’s our story, an incredible story of the journey toward faith and faithfulness, toward Bethlehem and new birth… 

1. …and it begins in fear and doubt. 

Don’t miss it. Don’t move too quickly to the scene of humble obedience. Mary’s first response was really pretty much what you would expect and probably pretty much like yours and mine would be in the same situation. In what must be incredible understatement, Luke says: 

…and Mary was greatly troubled and considered in her mind what sort of greeting this might be. 

Or as the Eugene Peterson translation says, “she was thoroughly shaken.” Other versions translate the Greek word as “deeply perplexed” or “greatly perturbed”…and I’ll bet she was! I’ll bet she was scared to death! Her first response was not faith, but fear. So much so, in fact, that before the angel could get on with the message, he first had to calm her down, saying, “Don’t be afraid.” And her second response wasn’t much better. It was pure disbelief. “How can this be?” Or translated into our vernacular, “You’ve got to be kidding! I mean, really, who put you up to this? How can this be happening to me?” 

Now I am not sure why that should surprise us, since it is the same first response of everyone else in the story: 

  • Zachariah and Elizabeth: surprised and shaken, and the angel had to say, “Don’t be afraid.”

  • Joseph: doubting and frightened, and the angel had to reassure him, “Don’t be afraid.”

  • Shepherds: stunned and scared, and before the angel choir could break into joyous song, they had to repeat the same message, “Don’t be afraid.”

Because in every case, the first response to the annunciation is not faith but fear, not belief but doubt.   

Fear, uncertainty, doubt, questions, reservations—isn’t that where most of us find ourselves…not just at the beginning of the journey, but maybe even now, maybe even here, maybe even today? We’d like to think that if an angel appeared to us, we’d jump right on the bandwagon. We’d be eager to follow where God might lead, willing to do God’s work. But my guess is that we know ourselves well enough to know that’s not the case. We are more like the man who came to Jesus asking for healing for his son, and when Jesus asked if he believed, the man said, “Lord, I believe, help my unbelief.” (Mark 9:24) ­Right there, side by side, belief and unbelief, doubt and faith, fear and hope. 

Or maybe we are more like St. Paul who says, “I don’t even understand my own actions—the good that I want to do, I don’t do, and the evil I don’t want to do, that’s what I do!” (Romans 7:18) The mix of good and bad, faith and doubt, courage and uncertainty—that’s where the journey toward Bethlehem and new birth begins for Mary, and that’s where it begins for me.  

2.   So Mary’s journey toward Bethlehem and new birth begins about where ours begins, and it moves toward acceptance and faith.  

You see, at some point you simply have to decide who you are going to trust. At some point in each of our lives there comes a moment when we have to make a choice. Follow logic as far as it will go, ask all the questions you can muster, wrestle with doubts and fears until you come to a point where you have to make a choice. And the only way that makes any sense is to say, even with trepidation and lingering doubt and fear, “Yes…I guess…let it be.” 

Author Jeff Edmondson describes a time when he was wrestling with his faith and future, trying to discern where God was leading, and his brother challenged him with some really tough questions. He says it would have been easier to just go with the flow, but his brother forced him to deal with the tough issues instead of taking the easy road. Some years later, he said he was having dinner with his brother and reminded him of the conversation. “For the life of him,” Edmondson writes, “he couldn’t remember the conversation at all.” 

“Well,” Edmondson said, “whether you remember or not, your questions drove me to find answers about God’s will for my life.” 

His brother asked, “And what’s the answer?” 

“End of the day, it’s all about faith, gutsy faith.” 

And so he entitles his book: Gutsy Faith: Hard Conversations with God. (Jeff Edmondson, Gutsy Faith, page 11) 

And isn’t that what this story represents—Mary’s hard conversation with God, Mary’s gutsy faith? Just for this morning, can we pull Mary out of the romance of the sentimental, misty-eyed “Silent Night” just long enough to see her for what she was: 

  • a teen-ager struggling to understand herself and her relationship with God

  • a pregnant woman wrestling with the pressures of this pending motherhood and the responsibility which would be hers

  • a potentially unemployed single mom in a society which offered her nothing but disgrace

  • a fear-filled doubter, uncertain of what to believe

Just for today, see her, not quite yet as the venerated “Mother of God, Queen of Heaven,” but as the woman next door, the woman down the street, or better yet, as a woman on the street. See her as one of Hannah Montana’s hoards or as the teenager with the telephone surgically attached to her ear. 

Maybe if we can see Mary for who she was, then we can see her faith for what it was—tough faith, courageous faith, gutsy faith. If we can see her as the fearful doubter who comes to a point of gutsy faith, then we can hear her sing, not in the melodious, ethereal tones of Lennon and McCartney, but in strong voice of determined courage: 

Lord, let it be, let it be just as you say.

God, let’s go for it! I’ll give it all I’ve got. 

That’s “gutsy faith.” That’s Mary’s faith. That’s the kind of faith which can lead us toward Bethlehem and new birth.  

And that kind of faith can lead us to sing with Mary: 

  • about a God who is mighty and is ready to do great things

  • about a God whose mercy is on those who fear him

  • about a God who will scatter the proud, put down the mighty, lift up the lowly and fill the hungry

It takes gutsy faith to sing that kind of song. It takes gutsy faith to see the unseen.  

3.   The journey toward Bethlehem and new birth begins in fear, moves to faith, and ends in vision—seeing the unseen.  

It was December 1996. A water stain, 60 feet high and 20 feet wide, appeared on a plate glass window in an office building in Clearwater, Florida. Many people believed it to be a vision of the Virgin Mary. They came from across the country to gaze at it, stand before it, kneel before it, pray to it. Hundreds of candles lined the sidewalk below, until the city had to form a “Miracle Management Task Force.” (I love it…a task force to “manage” miracles! Exactly how does one “manage” a miracle?) 

By the time Christmas was over, they estimated that more than 400,000 people had come to see it, and the veneration continued for five years until a disturbed young man shattered it with ball bearings from a slingshot. Somewhat cynically, my brother writes of a friend who said, “I have a near-Catholic veneration of Mary, but I can’t think of one good reason why she would show up on the window of a mortgage finance office.” (Maybe if it were this year, it would make more sense!) 

A professor in my brother’s congregation just across the bay from Clearwater gave the scientific explanation—moisture on the outside of the window combined with smog and particles in the air; air conditioning blowing on the inside, sunlight hitting the glass just right, causing a certain refraction of the light rays. But he says as he watched the people responding to it, it reminded him that there are some things in this world which science can’t explain, and that even a water stain on a window can become a moment of insight for a spiritually hungry world, catching a new vision, sensing a new hope, looking for new birth, seeing the unseen.  

Right here, right now, the economists and the demographers can tell us all about what’s happening in our region, in our economy and in our world. But let me tell you another story: 

  • It’s the story of a family for whom Christmas came to life when they delivered Angel Tree gifts and the kids said, “That’s the best thing we ever did.”

  • It’s the story of a man who came in to pick up his poinsettias for delivery to some of our seniors and was disappointed to discover he only had two assigned to him this year.

  • It’s the story of dozens of volunteers who have been working at Cass this month in seemingly mundane tasks with a vision for the ministry and mission it can support.

  • It’s the story of a congregation which is close to pledging a budget of over $2 million in a day when many folks just couldn’t see how it could be done.

  • It’s the story of people who catch a vision of what God is doing in the world and with Mary are willing, in spite of their doubts and fears, to answer with a gutsy faith saying, “Yes, Lord! Let it be! Let it be!”

It’s the story of people who can see the unseen and are ready to make the journey toward Bethlehem and new birth…if only we have the eyes to see.  

I don’t know where you are on that journey this morning. My guess is we are all over the map. Some of us are with Mary at the point of fear and doubt—greatly troubled, not at all certain where God is and what God wants. Some of us are with Mary at the point of saying “Yes”—for the first time or the umpty-ninth time, saying, “Yes, let it be. Let it be.” And some of us are with Mary, ready to break into song—“My soul magnifies the Lord and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior.” 

Wherever you are this morning, I invite you to open your eyes. Catch a vision of God’s will and God’s work. Open your eyes to see the unseen. 

It’s not a Christmas carol, but perhaps it expresses the prayer of Mary and perhaps it is our prayer for the day: 

Open my eyes, that I may see

      glimpses of truth thou hast for me;

Place in my hands the wonderful key

      that shall unclasp and set me free.

Silently now I wait for thee,

      ready, my God, thy will to see.

Open my eyes, illumine me, Spirit divine.

                                                (UM Hymnal, 454) 

Note: 

The story of the vision of Mary in Clearwater, Florida comes from James A. Harnish’s Advent devotional book, Rejoicing in Hope.


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |