Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
Expecting the Unexpected

Sermon:
December 9th, 2007
Morning Services

Scripture:
Luke 1:5-25

The story really begins in a moment of poignant understatement. The story begins after the “but.” Somewhere along the way, someone told me, “Nothing matters before the ‘but.’”  You know, when people say: 

“I agree with you, but…”
“I loved the anthem today, but…” 
“Oh, that was a great sermon, but…”   

Luke gives this glowing introduction of Zachariah and Elizabeth:  

Division of Abijah, daughter of Aaron, both righteous before God, walking in the commandments of the Lord blameless…but…they had no children because Elizabeth was barren. 

Nothing else really mattered in a culture where it was believed that children were evidence of God’s favor, and therefore, the lack of children suggested God’s disfavor; in a religious faith which had no clear notion of the afterlife, and the only way one could endure beyond death was through their posterity. So without children there was no hope, no future, no reason for living.  

Barren. The word itself rings hard and cold against our ears, doesn’t it? Those of us who live in this part of the northern hemisphere know what “barrenness” is all about, don’t we? We understand what it means for fields to lay fallow. We know the darkness of winter, the hardness of frozen fields, the lifelessness of dried out cornstalks blowing in the freezing winter wind. The carol writer describes it with such eloquence: 

In the bleak midwinter, frosty wind made moan,

earth stood hard as iron, water like a stone;

snow had fallen, snow on snow, snow on snow,

in the bleak midwinter, long ago.  

(UM Hymnal, Page 221) 

That’s what winter barrenness feels like, doesn’t it? And of course, in the Bible, “barrenness” is not just a symptom of the weather and not just a matter of being childless. It is a metaphor for a condition of the soul, spiritual barrenness

·        times when the heavens seem hard as iron, when God seems distant and we feel frozen out at heaven’s gate

·        the hardness of heart that keeps us from really feeling the hurts of others

·        the hollowness of hope when we can’t even imagine a better world or better future

·        the sterility of folks who are closed to the possibility of new birth and new life through Jesus Christ

·        the infertility of self-centered saints who care only for their own salvation and have never had the joy of bringing someone else to birth as a child of God

·        the frigidity and rigidity of those who simply can’t believe that God has the power to do anything new, anything creative, any birthing of new possibilities in our lives or in the world 

In my brother’s Advent devotional booklet, he says: 

As we begin this Advent journey, some of us might confess that one of our deepest fears or frustrations in our faith life is that we sometimes feel as if all our praying, hoping and working for a better life and more peaceful world are nothing more than “visions of sugarplums dancing in our heads.”                   

(Jim Harnish, Rejoicing in Hope, Abingdon, page 6) 

That’s spiritual barrenness, and my guess is there were days when Zachariah and Elizabeth felt it—felt their prayers just bouncing off the ceiling, nothing more than fanciful, wishful but barren thinking. 

In my files, I came across an old sermon from one of my predecessors at Ann Arbor First, the incomparable Hoover Rupert. Well into his eighties, living in a retirement home in Maryland, he still teaches a Bible study class and reports he is working on writing another book. Preached in the late ’60s, the sermon’s title is “When Life Seems to Have No Meaning,” and the first section is “The Problem of Emptiness.” He says he believes our basic problem is one of emptiness and boredom. He quotes Dr. William Hubbard, then head of the U of M Medical School and member of First Church, who told a pastor’s conference: 

Humankind is experiencing a decline in a sense of satisfaction and a growth of uncertainty and impatience, of frustration and, in my opinion, worst of all, boredom.

                                                            (Ann Arbor News, Jan. 17, 1967) 

Emptiness. Boredom. Life without meaning. Spiritual barrenness. Ever feel like that? My guess is that some folks have even felt that way in church. 

And that brings us to Zachariah, in the temple.  

Luke tells us he was a priest of the Abijah, a good man, doing God’s work, carrying out his duties. There were so many priests, they couldn’t all be on duty all the time, so they served in rotating teams. And during each rotation, there were so many priests in each team, they couldn’t all have the plum job of entering the Holy Place and offering the incense, so they cast lots, rolled the dice. On this day the lots fell to Zachariah. It should have been the highlight of his career as a priest. Many priests never had the opportunity to carry out the high and holy task of offering the incense, lifting the prayers of the people to God. It should have been a time of great joy and a moment of spiritual exhilaration. But my guess is he came to that moment with the weight of his own disappointment weighing heavily on his heart: 

·        feeling the pain of Elizabeth’s embarrassment

·        questioning his own standing before God: “No children must mean God is pretty well displeased with me. What kind of a priest am I and what have I done to deserve this?”

·        doubting the power of prayer even as he offered them on behalf of the people 

Emptiness. Boredom. Spiritual barrenness. 

So he just kept going through the motions of worship, keeping the ritual, following the traditions, but expecting absolutely nothing. And my guess—no, my experience—is that he was not the last priest to come to worship like that.  

But then suddenly, unplanned, totally unexpected, he heard the last word he ever expected to hear: “Zachariah, thy prayer is heard. Elizabeth will bear a son.” 

Here, right in the midst of their boredom and barrenness, right at the point of their deepest disappointment and in the face of doubt and guilt and the feeling of faithlessness: Shazam! The unexpected surprise of God and unanticipated advent of the Spirit, the unbelievable encounter with the Holy. He was so shocked, he was, quite literally, speechless! And he stayed that way for nine months! (My guess is Elizabeth might have been pleased with that!) 

Do I give away my age when I remember the classic TV show with the familiar tag line? Allen Funt would end the show with the reminder: “Someday, when you least expect it, someone will say, ‘Smile! You’re on candid camera!’” And that’s how God often comes. Someday, when you least expect it. 

·        Moses, just tending his flocks, when suddenly the bush was burning and he took off his shoes because he realized he was on holy ground.

·        Isaiah, just going through the motions of worship in the temple, when suddenly it seemed the whole house was filled with smoke and he saw the Lord high and lifted up. God’s glory filled the temple and Isaiah’s life was touched with fire.

·        The woman at the well, just minding her own business drawing water for the day, and lo and behold, she discovered living water and she knew she would never thirst again.  

My friend, Gary Haller, preached a sermon at Grand Rapids First which he entitled “The Amazing Godwink.” Gary calls it the unexpected, surprising, amazing moment when it seems God winks and life can never be the same. (Gary Haller, “The Amazing Godwink,” Grand Rapids FUMC, June 11, 2006) 

That’s what happened for Elizabeth that day in the kitchen, going about her chores, carrying her sorrow, trying to dispel her disappointment and suddenly: Shazam! God winked and she discovered the stirrings of new hope, new life and new promise for her future.  

That’s what happened to Zachariah that day in the temple. Bored with his priestly duties, barren in spirit, he was just going through the motions, feeling that his faith was a fraud and his prayers were nothing more then smoke, when suddenly: Zap! God winked and all of life was new.  

Now, I can’t tell you when it will happen for you. I can’t predict when God will break in with a fresh, new insight, a renewed sense of hope in the face of despair, the new birth of new life in the Spirit. If I could tell you, then it wouldn’t be unexpected. All I can tell you is that if you watch and wait, if you listen, someday when you least expect it: Smile! God winks and all of life can be new.  

All I can say is, “Expect the unexpected.”   

With many of you, I love the writings of Frederick Buechner. His own conversion story parallels that of Zachariah and Elizabeth. He tells of his student days in New York when he was not a Christian and had very little in the way of a church background. But for some reason he had been drawn to attending church, listening to the great George Buttrick preach. Week after week.  Sermon after sermon… 

…then there came one particular sermon, with one particular phrase in it that does not even appear in the transcript of the sermon someone sent me 25 years later, so I can only assume he must have dreamed it up and ad-libbed it on the spot.

 

He said that Christ is King because again and again he is crowned in the hearts of people who believe in him. And that inward coronation takes place, said Buttrick, “amid confession and tears and great laughter.”  

Buechner writes: 

It was the phrase “great laughter” that did it. Did whatever it was that must have been in the doing all the years of my journey up till then. Here, at the end, I am left with no other way of saying that what I found was Christ. Or was found. It hardly seems to matter.                       

(F. Buechner, Sacred Journey, page 108) 

Just a phrase…“great laughter.” Just a word…one which the preacher seemed to conjure up out of thin air. And in an instant—unanticipated, unplanned, unexpected—God winked and his life took an entirely new direction.  

I can’t tell you when or where it might happen. It might come as it did for Elizabeth, in the midst of barrenness and brokenness, at the point of her greatest disappointment. It might come as it did for Zachariah, while going through the motions, in emptiness and boredom. It might come as it did for Buechner, in an unplanned phrase or barely spoken word. All I can say is, expect the unexpected. Because someday, when you least expect it: SMILE! God will wink and life will become new.  

How silently, how silently,

      the wondrous gift is given;

so God imparts to human hearts

      the blessings of his heaven.

No ear may hear him coming,

      but in this world of sin,

where meek souls will receive him,

      still the dear Christ enters in.

 

Notes: 

Dr. Hoover Rupert’s sermon, “When Life Has No Meaning,” has no date on it, but it was preached at First Church Ann Arbor in the late ’60s. The most recent reference is this quotation from Dr. Hubbard in the Ann Arbor News, January 17, 1967.  

Frederick Buechner’s conversion story is told in a couple of his books. I reference it here from The Sacred Journey. Several of his books are available in the Circuit Rider bookstore, or you can go to the “virtual bookstore” on our website (www.fumcbirmingham.org) to find a full listing of his works.  

My brother’s Advent devotional, Rejoicing in Hope, is also available in the Circuit Rider bookstore or the virtual bookstore.


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |