Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
Lost in Wonder, Love and Praise

Sermon:
December 2nd, 2007
Morning Services

Scripture:
Matthew 1:18-25

In Latin it is called the mysterium tremendum. The more pedantic English is not nearly as poetic. We would say “tremendous mystery,” so the Latin is more poetic and probably more powerful—mysterium tremendum. It is what theologian Rudolph Otto calls “The Idea of the Holy.” He says an encounter with this sense of the “holy” results in nothing less than stupor: “blank wonder, utter astonishment that nearly strikes us dumb.” (academic.brooklyn.cuny.edu/english/melani/gothic/numinous, “Otto on the Numinous”) 

Mysterium tremendum…tremendous mystery. 

And to be honest, in our scientific, Western culture, we aren’t much on mystery unless, of course, you are talking about suspense in fiction: Agatha Christy, CSI, Jonathan Kellerman. Suspense, meaning intrigue, danger. But mystery in the sense of wonder? Mystery as encountering the unknown? Mystery as the idea of the holy? I guess it’s just not our thing. We are probably more like the characters in Charles Dickens’ too infrequently read Hard Times. We want the facts and nothing but the facts with no room for fantasy or mystical experiences. Much of Dickens’ writing, including The Christmas Carol, was an attempt to speak out against the hard facts of his age, the Industrial Revolution, in favor of wonder, love, beauty, mystery, the holy. In much the same way, we find ourselves in a technological era when everything needs to be explained, understood and answered, and we aren’t very comfortable with truth beyond our grasp, knowledge beyond our understanding, wonder and mystery. 

But for the Eastern mind, the mind of the Bible, life is more than just the facts. Life is measured by mystery, not just the facts. In the Eastern mind, truth is better told in poetry than prose. Truth is communicated in parable and song, mystery and wonder. The Gospel writers tell the Christmas story in brevity and understatement, with this sense of mystery and wonder. It is a story filled with angel song and wandering wise men, a story told by star-struck shepherds, written by inspired dreamers. It is a story better told in poetry and song than in facts and prose.  

I suppose Matthew is the Gospel writer who comes the closest to our Western, twenty-first century mindset. Maybe Luke as well. He was a doctor, and at the outset of his Gospel he says he wants to offer an “orderly account” of all that has happened. But of all the writers, Matthew probably comes closest to thinking like us. He was a government civil servant, a tax collector, an IRS accountant, bean-counter, policy wonk. So he begins his Gospel, not with mystery and wonder, but with facts and dates, a long, detailed genealogy including everyone from Abraham to Azor, Shelhal to Zadok, Manassah to Matthian—names we don’t even note and people we really don’t care much about. Details…facts…logic. 

Then suddenly, in the midst of the mundane, a man has a dream, a virgin conceives a child, and in amazing understatement—only seven verses—Matthew captures the whole of the Christmas story. And the birth itself is wrapped up in one simple sentence: 

Joseph took Mary as his wife, but he knew her not until she had borne a son, and he called his name Jesus. 

Then follows chapter two—the mysterious visit of the mystical Magi, a narrative filled with mystery and wonder, stars and visions, dreams and journeys of faith. And it seems even old, logical, bean-counting Matthew gets caught up in the mysterium tremendum

This year marked the 300th anniversary of the birth of Charles Wesley. The Wesleyan revival spread on the notes of Charles’ music, filled with song—over nine thousand in all. One of his best known is not usually thought of as a Christmas carol, but in fact the first verse tells of the incarnation and the hope of Advent: 

Love divine, all loves excelling,

joy of heaven to earth come down.

Fix in us thy humble dwelling

all thy faithful mercies crown.

Jesus, thou are all compassion,

pure, unbounded love thou art.

Visit us with thy salvation,

enter every trembling heart.  

And the song ends with this eloquent phrase, which expresses the experience of the “holy,” the mysterium tremendum: 

            “…we are lost in wonder, love and praise.” 

And isn’t that what we are all after in Advent? 

An encounter with the holy.

Getting lost in wonder at the beauty of the gift,

      lost in the experience of love,

      lost in the angelic praise. 

1.  This Advent, can we get lost in wonder? 

Well, I figure if Judy could talk about our grandson at Advent by Candlelight, so can I. Our 18- month-old Ethan brought his mom and dad to visit a couple of weekends ago. One morning his mom and dad took off for some time apart in downtown Birmingham and left Ethan with…who else? Grandma and Grandpa! The three of us sat on the couch that morning for over an hour, doing nothing but putting a little Fisher-Price figure in a plastic baggie and zipping it up, then taking him out, handing him to Grandpa, putting him back again. For over an hour we were captivated by a Fisher-Price toy, a plastic bag and my grandson. For that hour, nothing else in the world mattered. And, of course, it was wonderful! Wonder-filled! Lost in wonder. Marilyn Brown Oden writes, “Holiness is that great simplicity, our elimination of everything that doesn’t really need to be there.” (Marilyn Brown Oden, Manger and Mystery, page 41) 

Lost in wonder.  

2.  During this Advent, can we get lost in love? 

I met with a couple last week who are planning to marry. We were working on the details for the service. They are swamped with the details of the flowers, the reception, the seating of the guests, ushers and arrangements. So in the midst of it, I said, “Okay, we’ve talked about the wedding, now let’s talk about the marriage. How did you two get together?” And they started to tell me how they met, their first date, falling in love. They interrupted each other. They giggled. They both teared up more than once, and while they were talking, almost unconsciously, his arm moved around her shoulder, she snuggled over against him…right there in the Wright Parlor, no less!! They were lost in love. 

Of course, there would be time to talk about wedding dresses and receiving lines, ring bearers and flower girls and all the challenges of building a good marriage. But for that moment, they were simply lost in love.  

I think that’s how Joseph must have felt. He loved Mary so much, Matthew says, “he was not willing to embarrass her in her pregnancy;” loved her so much, he was willing to take her as his wife; loved her so much, he was with her to help her give birth.   

Can we get lost in love for the God who has loved us with a love divine, a love which excels all loves, lost in the joy of heaven to earth come down?  

3.  And this Advent, can we get lost in praise? 

“And they called his name Jesus,” and we have been calling him by that name ever since: 

lost in praise to the God who comes to us in a baby,

lost in praise to the God whose name is Emmanuel,

lost in praise to the God who has redeemed us, God with us.  

Lost in wonder, love and praise.  

Maybe it will happen in a song, maybe even “musak” in Macy’s or an anthem in worship. Maybe you will hear it in a word that is spoken, which speaks to you in a way no one else hears. Maybe it will come in the miracle of new-fallen snow or the silence of a moonlit night. Or maybe it will come in broken bread and shared cup. The mystery. The tremendous mystery, mysterium tremendum.  

Let it happen this Advent.


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |