Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
Called to be a Christian Community:
2. Cracked Pots and Clay Jars

Sermon:
September 30th, 2007
Morning Services

Scripture:
II Corinthians 4: 1-18

I suppose one of the reasons I love Norman Maclean’s book and Robert Redford’s movie, A River Runs Through It, is because there are precious few movies which paint clergy in a good light. Few movies are so painfully honest about PKs (preacher’s kids) and the family life in general, with all the joys and sorrows that go along with it. Also, it is just such a beautiful movie, set in the majestic mountains of Montana, the rolling, rocky fishing streams, and the small town life of the Presbyterian preacher and his sons. 

I remember the scene where Norman comes back home to Missoula from Cornell University. He’s been away for six years, returning now to his small hometown on the plains. The first night, his father calls him into his study, invites him to sit down and, in his very formal Presbyterian way, tells his son how proud he is of his study and his degrees. Then he asks, “And to what use shall you put this achievement?” Somewhat sheepishly and uncertain, Norman replies, “I’m not exactly sure…I’ve applied for some teaching positions.” 

His father questions further: “And do you find that rewarding? That is to say, do you feel this could be your calling?” 

Norman hesitates. His mother calls them to dinner, breaking the uncomfortable silence, and the question is left hanging. It is an eternal question which is never quite answered for certain, but it is the question which comes down to us today: Could this be your calling? 

Our theme for these weeks is all about God’s call to be a Christian Community: 

            God’s call and claim on each of our lives

            God’s commission for us as a community  

Last week we introduced Paul’s first letter to Corinth. This week, the second. It’s a fascinating letter, a lot like playing Jeopardy. It is as if we have the answers without the questions. Paul is obviously writing to address a variety of questions: 

  • troublesome questions of his own authority and intentions

  • lingering questions about a “painful visit” he paid to them

  • probing questions about their ministry, their generosity, church finances, theology and practice of the Christian life

Through it all, you can feel his passionate love for this fledgling church. At the very heart of it, he affirms their common calling to ministry: “Therefore, having this ministry by the mercy of God, we do not lose heart.” 

1.  Simply put…we have this ministry.  

For St. Paul, it’s not an option. It’s not a choice. It is a given—this calling of ours to serve in the name and spirit of Jesus Christ. It is a ministry which has been entrusted to all of us, a calling of God placed upon all who are part of the Body, a task given to us by the mercy of God. We have this ministry. In the United Methodist Church, we affirm that ministry is not the work of the clergy, it is the work of the whole people of God in service in the world. 

During the years I was at Dexter, Don Strobe was the preacher at First Church Ann Arbor. He was and still is one of my mentors, and I considered it a great honor to be one of his successors in that pulpit. Now in his retirement, even after a stroke, his sharp, creative mind and powerful voice witness to the truth of the Gospel.  

He is also a great storyteller. Don once told a story which he said came from a meeting of the school board in Fort Worth, Texas. It had been a particularly contentious meeting in a contentious time. In order to try to be conciliatory, at the end of the meeting, the superintendent stood up and said: “Now I know this has been difficult, and many of you may still have concerns.  I just want you to know that if you have any questions, you can always call this number.” He started to give a phone number when suddenly the assistant superintendent jumped up in the back of the room and said: “Hey! Wait a minute. That’s my phone number!” 

In our baptism, God has given our phone number to a hurting world. Through our covenant of membership in this church, God has put us “on call” as witnesses for Jesus Christ. We have this ministry, by the mercy of God. 

Here’s another good story from another good storyteller, Eddie Fox, the director of World Evangelism for the World Methodist Conference. Eddie tells the story of the man who injured his thumb at work. He went to his supervisor and reported it, and the supervisor told him to go to the clinic in the beautiful, big red brick building on the corner. 

When he walked in, he found himself in a small room with a desk, two doors and a sign over each door: “Injury—Illness.” It was his thumb, so obviously he went through the door marked “Injury,” and he found himself in a small room with a desk, two doors and two signs: “Internal—External.” So he went through the door marked “External” and found himself in a small room with a desk, two doors and two signs: “Major—Minor.” Well, it was just his thumb, so he walked through the door marked “Minor” and found himself in a small room with two doors and two signs: “Requiring Surgery—No Surgery Required.” He didn’t think this would take more than a few stitches, so he went through the door marked “No Surgery Required” and found himself in a small room with a desk with two doors and two signs: “Long-term Treatment—Short-term Treatment.” He knew this wouldn’t require long-term care, so he went through the door marked “Short-term Treatment” and found himself back out on the street. 

So he went back to work and the supervisor asked, “Did you find the clinic?” “Yes.” “Well, did they do you any good?” He responded, “Well, I can’t say as they did me any good. But you know, that’s the best organized place I’ve ever seen.” 

Now we Methodists are great when it comes to organization. But no matter how well organized we are, if we aren’t doing people good, we aren’t fulfilling our ministry: 

To share the good news of God’s love

To comfort the grieving

To welcome the stranger

To heal the broken

To care for the homeless

To carry out the unfinished work and witness of Christ in this world 

“We have this ministry, by the mercy of God.” 

Then St. Paul mixes his metaphors and shifts his focus… 

2.  We have this treasure in earthen vessels. 

The treasure—this priceless gift of the Gospel, this calling into ministry, this Word of salvation—we have this treasure in clay jars and cracked pots. 

Last week I talked about my Asbury College days. One of the “traditions” at Asbury was what we called “Senior Panic.” It usually happened in the spring semester, when graduating senior guys realized they hadn’t yet found a wife! Once they did find a willing woman, the next step was getting engaged. In the dorm, we would all strategize about how we were going to present the diamond to our intended. I remember Charlie Van Meter decided to give a diamond ring to his fiancé as the prize in the bottom of a box of Cracker Jack. We all thought it was silly and risky, but you see, St. Paul would understand. Like a diamond in a Cracker Jack box, like a pearl of great price found in a field, like a priceless gift in the bottom of a McDonald’s paper bag, wonder of wonders, God has chosen to entrust this ministry, this treasure, this gift, to folks like you and me. 

Listen to the Eugene Peterson translation of this passage: 

If you only look at us, you might well miss the brightness. We carry this precious Message around in the unadorned clay pots of our ordinary lives. That’s to prevent anyone from confusing God’s incomparable power with us. As it is, there’s not much chance of that. You know for yourselves, we’re not much to look at.

Just a bunch of clay jars and cracked pots. 

Bishop Will Willimon was for many years the chaplain at Duke University, and prior to that, a local church pastor. He tells a story from his days at Northside Church in Greenville, SC. He says it was the day of preparation for their “high holy days”—the annual Bazaar. 

Like all clergy, he was trying to hide away in the sacred sanctuary of his study to do something of eternal significance, when the president of the UMW burst into his office and said: “Unless you know how to unclog a kitchen sink, your only ministry right now is to find a plumber!” 

“Mind you,” says Willimon, “this was said to a seminary-trained, divinely-called, spirit-filled, episcopally-ordained man of God!”  

Willimon says:  

This is the church to which I have been called. This church with unpaid bills, air conditioners that don’t work, leaking roofs, clogged drains, altar guild clutter behind the communion table. It isn’t much of a church, but it is the only one we have been given. Nearly 2000 years after the first Pentecost, the church still looks like that gathering of Christians at 435 Summit Dr., Greenville, South Carolina. 

(William Willimon, “Corpus Christi: Carnal Thoughts on a

Spiritual Day,” Christian Century, June 3, 1981, page 634) 

St. Paul knew the Corinthian church wasn’t perfect. He knew all about the infighting over authority, the squabbles over spiritual gifts, the immorality, selfishness and pride, the caucus groups caucusing and fractions forming. But in spite of it all, he could still see them as the Body of Christ, the bearer of the Gospel—this ministry, this treasure in clay jars and cracked pots. 

3.  To show that the transcendent power belongs to God and not to us. 

Here, of course, is the good news. The good news is all about God’s transcendent power at work in us, God’s spirit in ministry through us, God’s grace being seen through us. And if that transcendent power could be seen through the cracked pots and clay jars of Corinth, there is hope for us.  

I hate to be the one to have to break this news to you, but this United Methodist Church of ours is not perfect. And though I hate to be the one to have to tell you this, the truth is that even this particular United Methodist Church—though it gets pretty darn close—might not be perfect. And though I hate to tell you, I suppose I might even go so far as to say your clergy aren’t perfect. And for that matter, neither are you. But it’s not really about us anyway, since the transcendent power belongs to God and not to us. 

Some of us grew up on “The Gospel According to Peanuts.” I remember a Peanuts cartoon where Charlie Brown is wistfully considering his future. He looks at his puffy little hands and says: “These are the hands which will one day accomplish great things. These are the hands which will some day do marvelous works. These hands might build mighty bridges or heal the sick or hit home runs. These hands might change the course of human history.” 

Then brash and ever-honest Lucy interrupts his reverie, grabs his wrist and says, “These hands have jelly on them.” 

Sure they do. But God has chosen to entrust his precious ministry and this priceless treasure into these stubby-fingered, jelly-stained hands. And in spite of our weaknesses and wanderings, our fumbles and foibles, God’s transcendent power can still be seen in us. 

When I was a youth back at Wesley Woods Camp, we used to sing: 

Let the spirit of Jesus be seen in me,

all his wonderful power and purity.

O thou spirit divine, all my nature refine

till the beauty of Jesus be seen in me.  

Had I known then what I know now about my ability to live that out, I might not have been so bold in the singing. But on the other hand, that’s just what St. Paul had in mind: 

We have this ministry, but the mercy of God;

we have this treasure in common clay jars,

to show that the transcendent power belongs

to God and not to us.  

Let the beauty of Jesus be seen in us. 

Let it be.

Let it be.


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |