Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
Called to be a Christian Community:
1. Ten Cats In A Burlap Sack

Sermon:
September 23rd, 2007
Morning Services

Scripture:
1 Corinthians 1-3

So what’s a family to do? In a family where he is Maize and Blue and she is Green and White, what happens when their daughter comes home to announce she is engaged to, of all people, a Scarlet and Gray Buckeye? And in the same week, they find out that a favorite nephew has just been offered a full-ride scholarship to play football for the Fighting Irish, while their darling niece takes off for med school at Penn State! What’s a family to do when the family reunion turns into a run for the roses? 

St. Paul had the same problem. The folks in Corinth were taking up sides, rooting for their favorite teams: 

            Paul’s Party

            Apollos’ Apprentices

            Barnabas’ Buddies

            Timothy’s Team

            Silas’ Sidekicks 

Like “ten cats in a burlap bag.”   

I think that’s another of those expressions I picked up in Tennessee, describing maybe the legislature, or something like that: “…the unity of ten cats in a burlap bag.” You get the picture. And if you don’t get it, how about another Southern expression which carries just a touch of arrogance: “It’s a Southern thing. You wouldn’t understand.” 

So welcome to Corinth! 

Paul himself had planted the church in this cosmopolitan seaport city of half a million people with a notorious reputation. Douglas Wingeier says it was known as “Sin City.” It was a busy commercial hub, reckless and powerful, brash and bold, the intersection of races and cultures (Roman, Greek, Jewish, Gentile, African, Arab) with a mix of languages from all over the Mediterranean basin. Here was the clash of great wealth and grinding poverty as immigrants flooded the harbors and streets in search of work. 

In this melting pot, Paul gathered a small band, most of whom he says were not rich, not well-educated, not powerful. And from that riff-raff, he formed a church and stayed for a year and a half. But when he left, it looks like he was hardly out the door when all the old rivalries and conflicts surfaced again. The Wolverines were at the Spartans’ throats, the Buckeyes were baiting both of them, and the Fighting Irish were claiming their special place in heaven, right alongside “Touchdown Jesus.” 

So Paul sends them several letters. He wrote at least one painful letter, a letter written in tears, he says. Perhaps it’s just as well we don’t have that one. But we do have two letters of encouragement and challenge, letters passionate with love, stern in discipline, and inspiring in spirit. In these letters he tries to focus their lives on their central mission, their calling to follow Jesus Christ, to be more than just a collection of individuals, the calling together in their life in Christ. 

In a recent survey of healthy churches, the researchers found that one of the primary characteristics was “…how church members relate to each other. Unhealthy churches are a collection of people acting individually, while healthy churches relate as a community.” (“Transforming Churches” by Kevin G. Ford, quoted by Kent Millard, St. Luke’s UMC, Communion, Sept. 2007, page 24) 

In short, we are called to be more than “ten cats in a burlap bag.” We are called to be a Christian Community.  

I’ve got two lessons to share with you this morning. To do so, I need to take you back forty years to when I was a freshman at Asbury College, a school well-known for its spiritual fervor, sending out young men and women who are both well-educated and spiritually grounded. The old slogan back then was that at Asbury they “take in heels, mend their soles, and send them out in pairs.” At least I got the last part right. I found a wonderful wife. 

To make a complicated story short, we had four presidents in the four years I was at Asbury. While other college campuses were aflame over the Vietnam War and Civil Rights, we were fighting over a poorly-chosen president and divisions in the community, creating incredible turmoil in the student body and faculty. All of this, of course, was surrounded by a cloak of spirituality—prayer meetings and political plotting, underground newspapers and Bible verses. Frankly, it was a whole lot like the church in Corinth.  

The first lesson I learned was “be careful about claiming to know God’s will.” Everyone seemed to think they knew exactly what God wanted in the situation, and I guess it taught me to be a bit tentative about making that claim. But that is another sermon for another text and another time.  

1.  Today’s first lesson is about unity in diversity. 

I don’t know who said it then or who said it first. When I googled the phrase, it took me all the way back to Nicholas of Cusa in 1464. But it was the lesson I needed as a college freshman, and it’s the lesson I try to relearn on a regular basis. It’s the lesson Paul tries to teach the Corinthians: “Unity does not demand uniformity.” In fact, St. Paul invites us to go a step further and actually celebrate diversity. St. Paul’s favorite image for the church is that of a body, with all its different and distinct parts, yet one in Christ. Unity in diversity.  

Yesterday’s New York Times had a front page article about the Baptist church in Clarkston, Georgia, just outside Atlanta, which has become a melting pot of international diversity as immigrants move into the town. The church has gone from being all white to a mixture of races and nationalities. The pastor said: “Jesus said heaven is a place for people of all nations, so if you don’t like Clarkston, you won’t like heaven.” (New York Times, Sept. 22, 2007) 

Right alongside it, I read the story of racial tensions in another small town in the South. And I couldn’t help but think: “How tragic. Whatever the facts of the case, how tragic that on the same weekend we mark the 145th anniversary of the Emancipation Proclamation, we are still dealing with racial strife in America.” 

And I thought about my days at Asbury College. Amid all the fighting and feuding, I remember a brass plaque on the wall quoting one of the school’s most famous alumni, E. Stanley Jones: 

Here we enter a fellowship. Sometimes we will agree to differ. Always, we will resolve to love and unite to serve. 

And in a day when diversity can become divisive, I am glad to be part of a church which honors diversity—where unity does not demand uniformity, where we cherish each other as unique children of God. I celebrate a church which really is a fellowship—where we may agree to differ, but we will always resolve to love and unite to serve. 

The first lesson from St. Paul is about unity in diversity: “Unity does not demand uniformity.” 

2.  Second lesson: Be careful what you put at the center. 

At Asbury in those days, I learned the difference between the center and the circumference. Well, actually I had learned it long before, but I came to appreciate it in a new way.  

I asked my elementary-school-principal wife if kids in school still use the compass. You know, a compass is that two-pronged thingy with a sharp point on one end and a pencil stuck in the other.  You put the pointer in the center of the page and then you can make a perfect circle with any size radius and diameter. You can draw a little tiny circle—exclusive, restricting, small and limiting—or you can stretch the compass and make a large circle going as far as your compass will reach. But it makes all the difference where you put the point, and how far you are willing to reach. There’s a big difference between the center and the circumference. Some things need to be at the center. Other things ought to be on the circumference. Some things matter deeply; other things are peripheral. 

It matters what you put at the center.  

As much as I loved Asbury College, I have to say, back then there were lots of things at the center which should have been at the circumference. Now remember, it was the ’60s. It’s hard to realize it now, in our day of buzz cuts and bald heads, but back then at Asbury we were fussing over men’s hair being too long (it couldn’t touch your ears or your collar) and women’s skirts being too short (they had to touch your knees). And you could only wear shorts on the athletic field, which means you had to wear sweat pants or slacks over your gym shorts, then take off your pants when you got to the football field! Quite a sight in itself! There was no mixed swimming in the pool. No couples were allowed out on campus after 6:15 p.m. We were majoring on minors and missing the point of Christian Community. It matters what you put at the center! 

St. Paul puts his pointer right at the center of all the Corinthians’ diversity and disputes: 

We preach Christ crucified—a stumbling block to some and folly to others, but for us, the very power of God.

 

(and)

 

For I decided to know nothing among you except Jesus Christ and he crucified. 

Of course, he then goes on and addresses everything from sexual immorality and speaking in tongues, church politics and poverty, worship styles and wealth, marriage and family and singleness, lawsuits and liturgy. He touches on all the issues of the day. But he knew the difference between the center and the circumference, and he made clear what was at the center: to know Jesus Christ and him crucified. 

Even as we speak, one of our sister churches—actually, the church of John Wesley, the church in which he lived and died, the Episcopal Church—is going through inner struggle and turmoil. Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams was in the U.S. this week, meeting with the Bishops to try to hold the church together. Williams once said:  

The slogan of the church ought to be ‘not without the other;’ no ‘I’ without ‘you,’ no ‘I’ without ‘we.’ 

He says this does not mean a kind of numb “herd mentality.” It doesn’t mean everyone’s individuality is submerged, or that differences no longer exist. He is not calling for “drab sameness.” But rather, he says believing in the church means believing that the other person is a unique gift God has given you to live with. It is the radical vision of a community of people who, in all their differences and diversity, are “immersed in the life of Jesus and invited to eat with Jesus.” (Rowan Williams, “In God’s Company,” Christian Century, June 12, 2007, page 23) 

Unity in diversity.

With Christ at the center. 

Tonight begins another Ken Burns TV classic on World War II. Some of you were there. Perhaps no site in England better represents the war and its aftermath than Coventry Cathedral. The old cathedral was destroyed in the great blitz, nothing left but ruins. When it came time to build a new cathedral, instead of clearing the land, they left some of the old ruins standing and built the new cathedral beside it, as a witness to the devastation of war and as a witness for peace. So you literally walk through the bombed-out remains of the old cathedral to enter the glorious new one.  

Steven Verney, the pastor at the time, told the story of the new cathedral in a little book called Fire in Coventry. He writes:           

The cathedral was burnt, and out of the ruins sprang new life, and the opportunity to discover in the 20th century what God really wills his church to be.

 

One tiny transformation is symbolic of the rest—our new cathedral is not exclusively Anglican, but holds within it a “Chapel of Unity.” So we must be ready to meet and learn from each other.

 

God’s demands are terrifying, and even more terrifying is his demand that we should love one another. But most terrifying of all is his invitation to let go, and to fall into his hands, so that he may take us, bless us, and break us, and give us to each other.

(Stephen Verney, Fire in Coventry, page 64) 

I like that. A chapel of unity right at the center.  

And once again, I celebrate a church that knows what’s at the center. 

A church where unity underlies our diversity. A church focused on Christ and him crucified. A church truly seeking to be: 

…one in the Spirit, one in the Lord.

We are one in the Spirit, we are one in the Lord.

A church where we pray that all unity will someday be restored.

Where others will know we are Christians by our love, by our love.

Yes, they’ll know we are Christians by our love.


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |