Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
Oh Say Can You See:
A Vision for Church and State

Sermon:
July 1st, 2007
Morning Services

Scripture:
Revelation 21:9-22:5

There has long been a tradition of melding and merging religion and the state. Ancient Egyptians believed the Pharaoh was divine, and so did the dynasties of China and Japan. In Christian history, Constantine merged church and empire—the combination of God’s Kingdom and the emperor’s realm—hence the “Holy Roman Empire” and the “Roman Catholic Church.” And today, look at the Islamic states where faith and state are merged as one. 

I am a lover of things British. I have always wanted to attend the “Last Night of the Proms,” the conclusion of that wonderful summer concert series now in its 123rd year. It always ends with the robust singing of national hymns ringing through the Royal Albert, all of which assume God’s unique relationship with the realm. First, “Land of Hope and Glory” to the tune we know as “Pomp and Circumstance”: 

Land of hope and glory, Mother of the free;

How shall we extol thee who are born of thee?

Wider still and wider shall thy bounds be set;

God, who made thee mighty, make thee mightier yet.           

Then “Rule, Britannia!” with the assumption that God and the angels had a hand in her creation: 

When Britain first, at Heaven’s command

Arose from out the azure main;

This was the charter of the land,

And guardian angels sang this strain:

Rule, Britannia! Britannia, rule the waves:

Britons never will be slaves. 

And finally, with gusto, William Blake’s glorious anthem with the historically and biblically questionable assumption that Jesus actually walked around the British Isles:

And did those feet of ancient times

walk upon England’s mountains green?

And was the Holy Lamb of God

on England’s pleasant pastures seen?

And did the Countenance Divine

shine forth upon our clouded hills?

And was Jerusalem builded here

among these dark satanic mills?

 

Bring me my bow of burning gold!

Bring me my arrows of desire!

Bring me my spear! O clouds unfold!

Bring me my Chariots of Fire!

I will not cease from mental fight;

nor shall my sword sleep in my hand

till we have built Jerusalem

in England’s green and pleasant land.

 (Last Night of the Proms CD, BBC, Sept. 10, 1994)  

Though one can debate whether Jesus’ feet actually roamed England’s green and pleasant land, it’s stirring indeed to connect the vision of the nation with God’s vision of the New Jerusalem. The best example from our own national hymnody would be my personal preference for a national anthem, Katharine Lee Bates’ eloquent “O Beautiful for Spacious Skies”: 

O beautiful for patriot dreams that see beyond the years,

thine alabaster cities gleam, undimmed by human tears.  

Like Britisher Blake, her imagery comes from the Book of Revelation and John’s vision of the New Jerusalem, the “City of God”—coming down out of heaven with gates of pearl, streets of gold and cities of gleaming alabaster, undimmed by human tears. 

Of course, we should be careful about equating God’s “New Jerusalem” with England’s green and pleasant land…or ours. God’s kingdom is always larger than any of our earthly kingdoms. 

And yet, on this Fourth of July... 

What can we say about that “patriot dream that sees beyond the years”? And what about our vision of the nation, and what is the role of the church in all this? Oh say, can you see—a vision for Church and State? I certainly don’t think St. John had 21st century America in mind when he penned his Revelation, but taken out of context, perhaps his vision of the “New Jerusalem” can inspire ours.

1.  IT IS THE VISION OF A CITY BUILT “FOUR-SQUARE.” 

John writes: “...and he who talked to me had a measuring rod of gold to measure the city and its gates and walls. The city lays foursquare, its length the same as its breadth, and he measured the city with his rod.” 

I went to Wikipedia to look up the word “four-square” and I got everything from “Foursquare clothing” and “Foursquare rum” to the game of “four square” and the “Foursquare Church.” (Note: After preaching this sermon, I was told that in fact the city of Birmingham is four square miles.) 

It is John’s vision as the symbol of the perfect city—life redeemed and renewed as God intended; a community where all was in balance, a city of equality and wholeness and justice; true, right, square, four-square. And I suppose it is an image consistent with Thomas Jefferson’s vision of a land of “liberty and justice for all,” a land where “...all are created equal and endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights; among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” 

Now let’s be honest. From the very beginning, we have fallen short of the vision. When Thomas Jefferson penned the words of the Declaration, he had no intention of including women, and the great compromise on slavery was the price for getting it passed. That, of course, would take a hundred years and another war to resolve. Today we are still wrestling with the vision vs. the reality. Like Thomas Jefferson, we still have blind spots and short-comings.  

But, “Oh say, can you see…” 

Can you still see the vision, the hope, the dream? 

  • Can we still envision a nation “e pluribus unum”—of the many, one; a nation of immigrants which celebrates unity in diversity?

  • Can we see a nation which regards the rights and dignity of all persons, foe as well as friend; where we would treat enemy and enemy combatants the same way we would want to be treated?

  • Can we still see the vision of a city undimmed by human tears, no mourning, no crying, no suffering, no hunger, no poverty, no homelessness, with liberty and justice for all; life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness?

That would be a city “four-square,” for sure.  

And what is the role of the church in such a city? 

  • To hold up the measuring rod of God, to be the conscience of the nation

  • To call for the nation to be measured by its highest values, not its lowest expectations

  • To point out the places where the city is crooked, where walls are out of plumb, out of whack

  • To be the measuring rod for a city “four-square”

This is why I believe there is a connection between pulpit and politics, preaching and public life.  The church, like the prophets of old, is called to speak the word of judgment to the nation, to lift up the vision before the nation and pray that God in his mercy would “mend our every flaw.” 

Oh say, can you see—the vision of a “city four-square,” and the church as the measure of the dream? 

2.  AND JOHN SAYS IT IS A CITY WITH GOD IN THE MIDST. 

He writes, “The dwelling place of God is with men…I saw no temple in the city, for its temple is the Lord, God the Almighty was in the midst of her.” 

Now frankly, this is a tricky one for American Christians. How do we affirm the place of God in our national life and still remain a land of religious liberty for all? How do we proclaim a nation “under God” and still protect the separation of church and state?  

As a kid, I learned my first bit of trivia, and my guess is those of you who are my age will remember it too. What is the longest word in the English language? Today there is another word which I can’t begin to pronounce, but at that time it was Antidisestablishmentarianism. I had no idea what it meant, but I knew it was the longest word. Today, I understand it describes a political philosophy opposed to the separation of Church and State, originally in support of the establishment of the Church of England as the state church. (www.straightdope.com/mailbag/ mantidis.html) 

By contrast, our founding fathers intentionally chose “DIS-establishmentarianism.” Colonial America had already seen its share of religious battles: 

  • Puritans who came here in part to get away from established religion, set about establishing their own, then banished some of their own members to Rhode Island

  • English and German settlers in Pennsylvania bickered over language differences, hence the split between English-speaking Methodists and their German-speaking brothers and sisters

  • While Anglicans were establishing their claim in Virginia

The founders had seen the power of an established religion in England when they opted for Disestablishmentariniasm. They birthed a nation committed not to one religion, but to the freedom of religion; the Church free from the control of the state, and the state free from the control of the Church. 

Writer Walter Isaacson says, “… though Thomas Jefferson’s spiritual beliefs were vague (he was a deist, not really a fully-committed Christian), one thing was clear: he wanted to keep religion and politics separate.” (Time Magazine, July 5, 2004, page 62) 

And yet, within the American experience there has always been a deep desire to make a space for faith, for religion, for God in the midst. 

Personally, I am an evangelical Christian. I hope to see all the peoples of all the world, including our nation, accept Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior. And there are times I think I would like to have the nation on my side, to look to city hall to help promote the Christian message. But in my saner moments, I know that as an American, the measure of freedom I grant to other religions is the measure of my freedom as well. All I ask is that the “city” makes space for God in the midst; space for other gods, other religions and the freedom to express them. 

And the task of the church in such a city? 

It’s our task to lift up the message of the cross, to share the power of the Gospel, to witness to the name of Jesus Christ as Lord, to speak the prophetic Word of God to the political and public life as well as the private life of the nation. 

Oh say, can you see—the vision of a city where there is space for God in the midst, and where the church speaks the Word of God to the city? 

3.  AND FINALLY, IT’S THE VISION OF HEALING FOR THE NATIONS. 

John says the river of life flows through this city, and on the banks of the river, there is a tree, the tree of life, “...and the leaves of the tree were for the healing of the nations.” 

What is the ultimate goal and vision? It is the healing of the nations. 

If God has blessed America, as I believe He has; if God has shed his grace on us, which I believe He has; what are we to do with that blessing? We are to be a channel, a river of wholeness and life, a blessing and the healing for the nations.  

I was in Europe in 2004 during the celebration of the 60th anniversary of D-Day, probably the last time we will see a gathering of D-Day survivors in Normandy, these heroes of the modern world. That day, the International Herald Tribune ran a full page article by John S.D. Eisenhower, the son of Dwight Eisenhower, with a large photo of the General on D-Day. He said he is often asked what his father would think if he were alive today. Of course, he is quick to say he has no way of knowing. But he does know how his father felt following D-Day and the end of the war. John Eisenhower wrote: 

The most fundamental conviction that the period in Europe imprinted on his mind was the cruelty, wastefulness and stupidity of war. He saw first-hand how it destroyed cities, killed innocent people, wiped out economies and tore up structures of civilization. He expressed his feelings eloquently in April 1953 when he said, “Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and not clothed. We pay for a single fighter plane with a half a million bushels of wheat. We pay for a single destroyer with new homes that could have housed 8,000 people.”
 

The younger Eisenhower goes on: 

Not surprisingly, the war that included D-Day had made a pacifist out of the man who bore the responsibility, its supreme commander. Throughout his presidency, he combined a policy of maintaining a military deterrent to war while at the same time extending the hand of friendship.

(International Herald Tribune, June 7, 2004, page 10) 

Beyond the battles of the present moment; beyond the swords and spears and chariots of fire, Oh say, can you see—the vision of this great nation as a source of healing for all the nations?  

Well, there you have it. It’s at least one preacher’s vision for church and state. It’s the vision of: 

  • A city “four-square,” and the church as the measuring rod, the conscience of the nation

  • A city where there is space for God in the midst, where the church is free to lift up its message

  • A city which is the source of the healing of the nations

I close with a paragraph from the great Harry Emerson Fosdick, from a sermon preached at Riverside Church during the Second World War: 

We talk all the time about backing these boys up, but are we going to back them up in the thing that the best of them are most hoping for? They will win the war—at what cost!—but we along with them must win the peace.

 

We cannot put party first, or economic self-interest, or absolute national sovereignty, or imperialistic greed, or racial prejudice. If we do we shall be rightly damned forever in the estimation of our offspring. We must put righteousness first.

 

Ah, America, our loyalty is yours. As in our father’s days, our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor are committed to you. But just because we love you, God help us to see that all the good fortune we want from you depends upon a prior condition: Seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness, and all these things shall be added unto you.

(Fosdick, Great Time to Be Alive, page 30)   

Oh say, can you see? 

Amen.


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |