Photo of Dr. Harnish
Dr. John E. Harnish
Senior Pastor
What Ever Happened to Norman Rockwell?

Sermon:
May 14, 2006
Morning
Services

Scripture:
Colossians 3:5-4:1

For those of a certain age, Norman Rockwell was the artist who captured our American way of life. Beginning in 1916, he painted over 300 covers for the Saturday Evening Post which have become classics in American art—everything from childhood adventures in the old swimming hole to moving tributes to war heroes, gentle laughter and deep sentiments. He imaged what we imagined life was, or could be, like in those days of my growing up.  

Along the way he also challenged some of the narrow attitudes and prejudices of the era and called us to a broader vision: 

  • His well-known “Freedom of Worship” is one of the “Four Freedoms” which he painted during the Second World War. All four hang in our hallway. It shows not just Christians, but the broad variety of religious traditions, all part of the American dream, with the words “each according to the dictates of his own conscience.”

  • His glorious vision of the multi-racial, multi-cultural world in which we live includes over thirty distinct faces, nationalities and costumes, and the words “do unto others as you would have them do unto you.”

  • And who can forget the powerful image of a brave little black girl in a white dress walking to school amid Federal agents, Rockwell’s statement against the evil of segregation and racial prejudice. Unfortunately, the title for that painting is still all too true and still present tense. He called it “The Problem We All Live With.”

I haven’t found one of his works specifically for Mother’s Day, but images of family abound, and the loving mothers imaged in his work come through as a tribute to all our moms. Today, I’m thinking of another of the Four Freedoms, “Freedom from Want.” It shows a warm image of a family joyfully gathered around the Thanksgiving table with Grandma presenting the turkey to Grandfather for carving. As I say, I’ve never figured out how you could carve the bird at the table without making a huge mess! The image was an icon of family life, right up there with Ozzie and Harriet, I Love Lucy and Father Knows Best. 

So what ever happened to Norman Rockwell?

The truth is, the world has changed and our experience of family has changed with it. The other truth is that even Rockwell’s world wasn’t as perfect as we wanted it to be. Ozzie, as we later learned, ruled the Nelson family like a tyrant, Ricky and Lucy’s marriage ended in divorce, and we learned that father didn’t always know best.  

What ever happened to Norman Rockwell?
What ever happened to “family”?
 

Today, if your extended family network is anything like mine, it includes: 

Single parent families
Multiple parent families
Childless families
Singles in families
Co-habitating families
Long-distance extended families
Multi-racial, multi-cultural and international adoptive families
Families which have been broken by divorce or struggle with grief 

It’s all there, around today’s family table.  

It’s also a time when we are willing to acknowledge that Mother’s Day can bring pain as well as joy. Some years ago in one of my former churches, I preached the traditional Mother’s Day sermon on traditional family life. Not a bad sermon, but in response I received this e-mail: 

I am sure you meant well in your sermon today, but did you consider those in the congregation who want children but can’t have them, or my daughter who suffered a miscarriage, or the couple who adopted a child but then the birth mother took him back?

 

What about single persons, or those who choose to remain childless? We had difficulty having children and always ran into the same thing on Mother’s Day. I realize this is something you can’t fully appreciate, but I ask for more sensitivity in the future. 

No, Norman Rockwell doesn’t live here anymore.
And for that matter, neither does St. Paul.
 

Which brings us to the reading of the morning. This text and its parallel in Ephesians can be troublesome for those of us who want to take scripture seriously, so we might as well begin with the toughest paragraph, the third paragraph, and St. Paul’s vision of relationships: wives and husbands, parents and children, slaves and masters. 

It’s really a set of three parallel couplets which need to be read together. The first part of each couplet acknowledges the realities of his world and gives advice to wives, children and slaves on how to live in it:

  • Women had no rights. They were literally property of their husbands, so St. Paul encourages them to live out their role in faithfulness to God.

  • Children were less than property. In the Roman world, fathers could cast them out at any time. The only alternative for children was to try to please God by their daily living in the world as it was.

  • And slavery was a way of life.  N.T. Wright says slavery was to Rome what electricity is to us. Even for St. Paul, freeing the slaves overnight was unthinkable.  (N.T. Wright, Paul for Everyone: The Prison Letters, page 186)  The best a slave could do was do their best in their work, trying to please God, not just their masters, by the quality of their labor.

The first half of the three couplets was Paul’s way of saying, “This is reality and this is how to make it in the world as we know it for now, for the time being…” 

BUT…the second half of each couplet lifts up the first glimmers of an entirely new vision. The second half of each couplet is the radical, unexpected word, the earth-shaking word, the word which, if taken seriously, has the potential to transform relationships:

  • “Husbands, love your wives,” and to the Ephesians, St. Paul adds to love them “as Christ loved the church and gave himself for it.” (Ephesians 5:22) What a shocking, revolutionary concept. The very notion of sacrificial, self-giving love as the pattern for marriage was unheard of.  It is, in fact, the new word, the word which will reshape the marriage covenant.

  • “Fathers, don’t provoke your children to anger.” The very idea that fathers should care about their children’s feelings and treat them with any degree of respect as human beings of worth was unheard of, but it has the potential to reshape the entire family.

  • “Masters, treat your slaves with justice.” Justice for slaves? No one had ever considered such a thing. “Remember,” he tells the masters, “you also have a Master and that Master shows no partiality.” Now, if you begin to take that seriously, it will undermine the entire framework of ethnic superiority and racial prejudice.

It is as if Paul is saying, “I know what it’s like in the real world, but here are the seeds of a vision which ultimately will create a new world of relationships, marriage and family, parents and children, masters and slaves, race and nation.” Here is the word which will create a whole new community where, as he tells them earlier, there can no longer be Greek or Jew, circumcised or uncircumcised, barbarian or Scythian, slave or free, male or female, young or old, urban or suburban, Groves or Seaholm, Methodist or Baptist, Michigan or Michigan State, rich or poor, black or white, red state or blue state (I added some of that)…but Christ must be all, and in all. Or as Eugene Peterson translates it: “From now on, everyone is defined by Christ, and everyone is included in Christ.” (Colossians 3:10) 

St. Paul’s words on marriage and family are set in the context of the two preceding paragraphs where he tells us what it takes to build healthy families, homes, human relationships, community.  He tells us what to take up and what to leave behind. Put to death infidelity, promiscuity, evil desires, selfishness. Put away anger, gossip, foul talk, lying. Instead put on compassion, kindness, meekness, patience, forgiveness, and above all, put on love which binds everything together. And then he builds to this beautiful benediction, a word of blessing and promise for the family and home, nation and world: 

Let the peace of Christ rule in your hearts, and be thankful. Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly. Teach one another in wisdom, and sing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs with thankfulness in your hearts to God.

 

And whatever you do, in word or deed, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him. (Colossians 3:12-17) 

In the face of all the changes in the make-up of “family,” here are truly lasting “family values” which can make all the difference. 

In 36 years as a pastor, I have been humbled and privileged to be welcomed into the homes of the congregations I have served. And in the process, I’ve seen too many homes (and may I add, churches) where infidelity, anger, lying, gossip or bad-mouthing each other has undermined even the possibility of healthy relationships. St. Paul says, “Put all that to death. Get rid of it.”  

And in 36 years of ministry, I have also been blessed to be invited into countless homes filled with compassion, kindness, forgiveness, patience and forbearance (that means putting up with each other)—homes where people sing songs and tell stories, where the home was filled with laughter and thankfulness (even common courtesies like saying “thank you”), homes where whatever they do, they try to do it as if they were doing it in the name of the Lord. Certainly not perfect homes—there is no such thing—but homes where the peace of Christ has a chance to thrive and the word of Christ can richly dwell, where love binds everything together. Here’s a model for family and home—regardless of its configuration—that even Norman Rockwell would like.  

Well, I started with the image of Norman Rockwell’s Thanksgiving table. And let me say, I firmly believe in the importance of the family dinner table, but that’s another sermon for another Mother’s Day. Here’s another image of another table, maybe not as picture perfect as Norman Rockwell’s, but perhaps more like the families most of us live in. It comes from Robert Capon’s book on marriage and family called Bed and Board. The last chapter is entitled “Dinner at Our House”: 

I look down the table over which I preside. I feel like God partway through creation. Before me stretches a chaos only half turned into a world. Self, wife, sons, daughters, dishes, silver, food. Where is the Holy City in all of this? Why is it so long in forming among us? My carving tools rest on an intractable leg of lamb. Unfortunately, others are already talking. Creating is hurling back a flood of caveats and non placets at its creator. My first-born must have no gravy. The third-born begs off mushrooms. “This piece is all fat.” “I can’t eat that many carrots.”

 

“Quiet!” I shout. It’s pretty negative, but it works, and in the shuffling stillness the kind of order comes again. I quote to them St. Paul on the subject of pots talking back to potters. I remind them that we are the children of God, not a mob. The oldest one agrees. My heart lifts.
 

But just about that time, the youngest one knocks over her milk. Down toward me it races like a flood across the land. I jump up and back, but over the edge it pours and I am hit; right trouser leg, below the knee. It’s the third time this meal, and the thousandth today. My largesse is as nothing next to the cataract of milk she has produced in three short years. She has spilt it backhand, side arm, forehand and elbow first.  She has upset glasses with her head, her feet, her shoulders and knees; with her rump, her belly and the middle of her back. And with endless variety of time and circumstances. Upon thick tablecloths, yielding a white swamp which spreads ominously toward us all; or upon plastic tablecloths for a high-velocity attack. (I can remember only one successful escape from milk spilled on plastic. I nearly broke the chair to do it.)

 

At that moment someone yells, “Michael hit me!” In all my years with them, I have never actually seen it happen—how they manage the surreptitious right to the ribs, or the invisible elbows in the solar plexus. All I see is the mayhem which follows. Two are arguing and three are talking at once. The city has collapsed again and the jungle returns.

 

Finally my wife serves the chocolate soufflé with whipped cream, which draws us all together in praise.

 

It’s not quite the heavenly city, but neither is it chaos. We are the solitary set in family, and I love them all—their faces, their voices, their bodies, their minds; and I thank them for their company during these long short years together.
                    (Robert Farrar Capon, Bed and Board, page 167) 

May it be so at our tables and around this table.
May it be so in our marriages, our families and in our church family.
May the peace of Christ rule in our hearts.
May the word of Christ dwell in you richly.
And may love bind everything together.   

 

* * * * * * * 
 

Notes: There are numerous websites on the work of Norman Rockwell, including the Norman Rockwell Museum in Vermont, www.normanrockwellvt.com. Prints of the “Four Freedoms” hang in the hallway outside Runkel Chapel.  

The sermon includes a quotation from one of my favorite books on family life, Robert Farrar Capon’s Bed and Board. I have included a longer version of the passage here than I used in the actual preaching of the sermon. The book is out of print, but you can find copies available through www.alibris.com, a used book site.  

For a further discussion of a contemporary understanding of St. Paul’s advice on human relations, see Paul for Everyone: The Prison Letters by Tom Wright, available in paperback through the virtual bookstore on our website, www.fumcbirmingham.org. (JEH)


 


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |