Photo of Rev. McIlvenna
Rev. Lisa McIlvenna
'Tis a Gift to Remember

Sermon:
May 25, 2003
Morning Services 

Scripture:
John 15:9-17

In this week’s Steeple Notes article, I wrote about how, as a child, Memorial weekend was traditionally celebrated by playing and marching in the band at the cemeteries near our home. At each cemetery, we played patriotic songs and heard various speakers tell once again heroic stories of men who gave their lives for our freedom. No matter how many times I experienced it, always the echoing and haunting sound of the lone bugle player playing taps and the seven gun salute would bring a lump to my throat and tears to my eyes. 

As the years have gone by, I must admit that I have not only ceased going to the cemetery on Memorial Day, but I have become less and less enamored with the patriotic songs, waving flags, red, white and blue colored decorations and the heroic words of military leadership. In fact, if the truth was told, my own life experience has led me to the place where I abhor violence of any kind and do not believe in war. I also find myself disagreeing with the basic philosophy, teachings and what I believe to be abusive disciplinary regime that happens in many military camps.   

Don’t misunderstand me. I am proud to be an American and appreciate and value the freedoms we have as Americans. But I am also often embarrassed, ashamed and regretful of how too frequently my privileges and freedoms seem to be fought for and won at the cost of other’s freedom, dignity, basic rights and needs or lives, and how the pride I share as an American is too often, and perhaps accurately, perceived as ethnocentric prejudice and greed.   

What I didn’t mention in the Steeple Notes article is that this weekend also marks the anniversary of my brother’s unexpected death of a brain aneurysm three years ago. Like many of you who find yourselves smiling and/or shedding a tear as your mind reflects back through the memories of time spent with a deceased family member or close friend, this weekend invites me to a time of remembering the life I shared with my deceased brother.   

While I loved my brother very much and we shared an emotional bond that grew stronger with age, much of our childhood was spent with the love/hate relationship that often happens between siblings. It started the day that I learned that I had a new baby brother. I was angry with my mother because the baby was a boy and not a girl, and told her not to bring the baby home.  Five years younger than I, I often felt “put out” because I was being asked by my mother to “watch my little brother.” When I wasn’t asked to look after him, still he tagged along after me and tried to involve himself in all of my, and my older brother’s, activities.  

By no means was Randy, my younger brother, an easy child. Today he probably would be diagnosed with ADD or ADHD and put on medication. Not only was he a constant challenge for my parents, but for anyone who he perceived as an authority figure. He was a challenge for his teachers, his principals and anyone he didn’t agree with at the moment. He was very bright, but if the subject didn’t interest him or offer any benefit for him, he couldn’t be bothered.  

In addition, there was the world’s pace and then there was Randy’s pace. Therefore, while he scored high on academic achievement tests, his grades were always mediocre to poor. It took him five and a half years to complete college. After completion of college, Randy received a job with a promising future. Yet, given the opportunity of moving up the ladder, he and his wife opted instead to build a home in North Dakota. Or at least start to build a home. When he died, they had lived in it five years and it still wasn’t finished. 

In North Dakota, Randy settled on a low-paying job teaching in a vocational high school on an Indian reservation. It was a school where the students had little motivation and were there simply because the government paid for it. Statistics showed that the vast majority of the students would return to the reservation and to a life of alcoholism, spousal abuse and minimal or no employment. Ah, enough of memory lane. 

What does this have to do with today’s Gospel reading? In this passage from John, we find Jesus gathered with his disciples in the Upper Room. It was on the night of his arrest and these verses are part of his longer farewell speech as he attempts to prepare his disciples for his coming death.  Like many who are facing death, Jesus is reviewing his life: what he has done, who he has been, what his life has been about. He is also wondering what words of love, encouragement and hope he wants to offer to those he is saying goodbye to. In doing this, he not only models a healthy way to face death, but he gives both his disciples and us a special gift: a gift worth remembering! 

If Jesus had not offered this discourse and we were left to make sense of Jesus’ life or to write his epitaph, we might be as mistaken as the people of his day who both mockingly and half-heartedly inscribed on his epitaph, “King of the Jews.” We might be inclined to engrave the words “Wonder Man,” “Great Healer” or “The Miracle Worker” after focusing on the great works that he did, such as healing the deaf, the blind, the lepers, and the demon-possessed. Also how he multiplied the loaves and fish, walked on the water, turned water into wine, raised Lazarus and the young girl from the dead, or how he, himself, came back to life.    

In this passage, Jesus teaches what his life was really about and what he most wanted to give to others: LOVE. Furthermore, the real honor and value of his life comes from our savoring that love and sharing it with others.   

Love… What is love? Today we say that we love everything from a member of the opposite sex that we are attracted to, to fried chicken. We love our dog, our wife, our children, chocolate and pickles. To some people, “love” is nothing but sexual desire. For others, it is the lump you get in your throat or the knot you get in your stomach when you are in the presence of a special girl or boy.  

Some parents are too strict or controlling because they “love” their children and want them to speak and behave correctly. Others are too permissive because they “love” their children and can’t bear to correct them. Some marriages fall apart because they are founded on a selfish sentiment called “love.” Other marriages last a lifetime because their love is an unselfish balance of give and take, expressed in mutuality.   

What makes the word “love” so tricky? It is because in the English language, we love in so many different contexts. And unless we consider the context to see what sort of love we are talking about, it is not clear.  

In the New Testament Greek, there are four different words for love. The first kind of love is storgé. Storgé is the kind of love that you might have in families. It is the love between parents, and brothers and/or sisters.  

The second kind of love is philos. Philos is the kind of love that speaks of affection for another person. It is the love that you might find with a close friend and/or someone in your social group.  

The third type of love is eros. Eros is the kind of love that is passionate love and is often conveyed in sexual terms. It is the love that you might find with a spouse, boyfriend or girlfriend.  

The fourth type of love is agape. Agape is the kind of love that is spoken about in today’s scripture. It is a practical love. It is not the kind of love that leads you to do something nice because you have a warm, fuzzy feeling about the person. It is the love that allows you to be loving, even though the person is unlovable. It suggests a certain forgetfulness and  sacrifice as you act toward another’s highest good or interest. It is this kind of love that Jesus speaks of in his scriptures. Not only does he express it as his greatest desire for us and prescribe it as the only way to know joy in our life, he also spends several verses helping us understand what it is. 

Take a moment to look at what he says. First, agape love is sacrificial. A person can have no greater love than to “lay down his life…” We may never be asked to physically die for someone, but agape love is about offering ourselves, our lives, our very being to others.  It’s about being vulnerable, open and honest with our minds and hearts.   

The story is told of an old African woman who had spent 70 years as a servant to a southern belle, from her childhood into old age. The mistress died and a neighbor came to offer comfort to the black servant. She said to her, “I am so sorry to hear of Aunt Lucy’s death. You must miss her greatly. I know that you were dear, dear friends.” The maid said, “No, not friends.” The neighbor said, “I know that you were. I saw you laughing and talking together many times.” “Yes ‘m,” said the servant, “That’s so. We have laughed together and we have talked together, but we were just acquaintances. You see, Miss Ruth, we ain’t never shed no tears. Folks have to cry together before they is friends.” 

While it may not be necessary to cry with every person we love, agape does suggest giving of oneself in a relationship, enough to know what brings tears to the other person’s eyes. It calls for compassion and empathy, which is different than pity. When we experience pity, we feel sorry for. When we experience empathy, we suffer with. And then we allow ourselves to be close enough to put ourselves in their shoes and wonder what they might feel and think. That is the kind of love that is agape love. It suggests a willingness to be inconvenienced in order to demonstrate our love. It won’t always fit in our schedule or our routine. Sometimes it asks us to be flexible and to set aside our personal desires, petty differences, or let go of our own agendas.  That is the first point about agape love. 

Jesus raises a second point about agape love. It is unconditional. It is not the kind of care or concern that we extend because of fear. Nor is it giving without seeking healthy boundaries, so that people are encouraged to help themselves. Nor does it mean to give of ourselves and expect something in return. Unconditional love is about being all-embracing and all-inclusive. It is about loving, even though others seem to be unlovable or are different. It is about letting others be who they are and acknowledging their “otherness” in its integrity, without meaning to control, dominate, manipulate or change. It suggests openness, respect and reciprocity, rather than a master/servant hierarchy.  

On Art Linkletter’s version of a TV show Kids Say the Darnedest Things, he interviewed a six or seven year old girl and asked, “What does love look like?” The girl answered, “It is when I allow Johnny to get in front of me at the water fountain.” Art smiled and said, “Well, you must love Johnny very much.” The girl responded, “No, I don’t even like him.” Perhaps the little girl knows what agape love is. It is when we act in the best interest of another person, even when we don’t like them or what they do. 

How do we do that? That brings us to the third point Jesus makes about agape love. Agape love is a gift that we are able to give only inasmuch as we allow ourselves to receive it. Jesus’ disciples could be stubborn, quarrelsome, selfish, ambitious and often presumptuous men. They insulted, ignored and disobeyed him at times. He did not automatically always feel love for them.  He was able to love them only because he knew and felt that God loved him. Jesus says that is the key to love. It doesn’t come from our willpower or our determined spirit, but it flows from a heart that has been loved. When we struggle to show kindness to someone who irritates us, or when we struggle to forgive someone who has hurt us, our healing and ability to do so lies in our renewing our memory of Christ’s love for us. In solitude, we can share our feelings with God and be healed of them and be reminded of how God cares for us, supports us, forgives and encourages us, even in our humanness. It is when we abide in that sort of love that we come to recognize God’s Spirit within ourselves and within every human being. It is when we recognize this Spirit in ourselves and others that we can see beyond the differences, ugliness and hurt, and not only recognize the gift of Christ in each person, but allow ourselves to use that gift to bring healing and meaning to our own lives and to experience true joy and wholeness. 

Intentionally, I started this sermon sharing less than positive thoughts and feelings about both my brother and the spirit of American patriotism. Not to suggest that I am ungrateful for either my brother or the soldiers that gave their lives, but rather to illustrate how my experience of agape love with each has brought healing, meaning and joy to my life. It is with my own experience of God’s love in my life, despite all my shortcomings and quirks, from my experience of finding the Spirit of Christ within, that I am able to find it in my brother and in the soldiers who gave their lives for our freedom.   

In the case of my brother, I had the opportunity to visit the school where he worked when I went out west for his funeral, and to see the latest project he worked on with his students. He was supposed to teach them basic math skills. What I saw was a nearly finished, beautifully constructed house. Recognizing that part of the lack of motivation with his students was due to the fact that the students had to sit, read books and learn things that they would never use once they returned to the Indian reservation, Randy found that he could teach them math skills while teaching them a useful, practical and employable skill: building construction.   

As one who irritatingly gave so many trouble, and who always marched to the beat of a different drummer, Randy’s compassion and love, his ability to see the Christ in his students, empowered him to think and teach “outside of the box.” Today, I savor Randy’s gift of compassion and I choose to honor it and to allow myself to be challenged, to think and act in ways that are “outside of the box.” 

Likewise, while I may disagree with war and much of today’s military strategy, hearing and reading the stories of men and women who unselfishly gave of themselves and their lives for others, helps me to see the Christ in each. And not only do I savor their agape love, but the heart-prints that they leave in my life leaves me with the challenge to ask: What am I willing to die for? For what cause will I leave my husband and children to face months or years of hardship, danger or possibly death? 

Perhaps it is not enough for me to say that I am opposed to war, injustice, poverty, economic or racial inequality, but rather I need to ask the question: What am I willing to risk to prevent it or change it? 

Today is the Sunday of Memorial Day weekend and each one of us is left with our own reflections as we remember various people who have passed from our lives. In your reflections, may you wonder: Am I able to recognize and savor the gift of Christ in each person’s life? Does recognizing that gift help to give meaning and direction to my life? How will I pass the gift on to others?  

And what about my own life? Does it know the Christ within? Is the gift that I offer to others agape love? ‘Tis a gift to remember.