Photo of Jeff Nelson
Jeff Nelson
Cracked But Not Broken:
Thomas' Encounter With The Wounded Healer

Sermon:
April 11, 2004
Easter Sunday

Sunday Night Alive
 

Scripture:
John 19:24-29

Monologue 

I’m surprised so many came out tonight. Sometimes we get so caught up in the excitement of Easter—and it is exciting—that it seems like all of creation bursts into the “Halleluiah Chorus” on Easter morning. But Easter evening is important, too. It has its own story to tell, and it’s an important one. 

You see, for disciples like me and the others, this is when we began to make sense out of everything we had seen, not only in that last week, but in that whole year we had journeyed with him. It wasn’t until we came back together on Easter night and stood in this place, this Upper Room, that we began to put the pieces together about what had happened and what was going to happen. 

Oh, I’m sorry. I got ahead of myself. I should introduce myself. I’m Thomas. It’s all right, go ahead and laugh. Everybody does when they hear my name. I know what you’re thinking, and it’s true. I’m the doubter. And I have heard all the jokes. “Hey, is Thomas here?” “I doubt it.” “Does Thomas know what’s going on?” “I doubt it.” Very funny. 

But it’s true. I have always been a little on the skeptical side. My mom would always say about my growing-up years, “That Thomas never fully believed something until he saw it.” They always told me great stories about what vacations were going to be like, when we were going on these pilgrimages or trips. “Oh, it’s just going to be great, Thomas.” I wouldn’t believe it until I got there. My mom was always saying, “Thomas, Thomas, stay away from the cooking fire.” I didn’t believe it until I touched it.   

So they call me The Doubter. But you know, is that such a bad thing, really? I don’t even like to think of it as doubting—more like a reasonable person or a critical thinker, maybe a bit of a skeptic. Is that so bad? I mean, I’m not one to run and jump off any cliff just because everybody else is doing it. I like to put a firm foot on a bridge before I decide to cross it; eat around the crust a little bit before I bite into the full loaf. I mean, it’s just the way I’ve always been. A doubter. 

But I have to be honest with you. Things have really changed a lot in my life this last year. In fact, my whole outlook on the world really changed. It has happened ever since I met him. You know, he just had this whole other way of looking at the world. He had this whole other way of being in the world. In fact, when we were with him, it seemed like the whole world was different. And over time, this doubter started to become a believer—a believer that a new world was possible and new way of being could actually happen. I mean, the things that he could see in people that they couldn’t even see in themselves! 

You see, I have always been a guy who thought the world was just the way it was. There’s no sense in getting all worked up about it, no sense in getting worked into a frenzy. Things are just the way they are. I always thought the poor would just get poorer, the sick, sicker, and the suffering more insufferable. Then I met him. And he could see beyond what was on the outside of people. He saw beyond their infirmities. He saw beyond their brokenness, beyond their diseases. He saw in them things they never saw in themselves. He saw in me things I didn’t see in myself. And pretty soon this doubter was starting to become a believer, a believer that maybe the last would be first or maybe that you could really love your neighbor as yourself. Maybe you could really love your enemies. And then he’d say this thing all the time. He’d say that the Kingdom of God was near. He said it was at hand. He’d hold out his hand and say, “It’s this close.” And when you were with him, it really felt like it was there, like it was about to happen. 

I am sure you all know who I’m talking about. His name was Jesus. I’m sure you’re here today because you know his name. But I hope you know his story, too. I hope you get a chance to enter the story. I came to it with all kinds of doubts. Yet slowly, but surely, this doubter became a believer. But it wasn’t easy. Because you see, just when I was really starting to buy into this, just when I was about to sign my name on the dotted line, it all crashed down. It was all over. It was all over like that. All of the hopes, all of the dreams, everything that we had pinned our hopes on was gone. He was crucified, dead and buried. And with it, every dream we had for the future seemed to be gone with him. 

At that moment, I felt like a chump. I was thinking that I should have just stuck to my old doubting ways. All this talk about love, all this talk about hope, all this talk about wholeness—it’s good stuff. But it just sets you up, really. That’s what I was thinking at that moment. I said, “I’m not going to do this again.” Call me Doubting Thomas. It’s a lot safer road to walk, I was thinking. 

To be honest with you, I don’t know what the rest of the guys did. We all just took off. We all just ran away. I found out later that they all went back to the Upper Room and locked themselves in. They locked the door. Locked it, I’m sure, for their own safety. But locked it also to protect themselves from the embarrassment, shame and hurt. They’d be silly to allow that to be seen by anybody other than those who had been through it. 

But not me. I didn’t want to be with them. You see, I ran off and was by myself. I just needed to be alone. I went somewhere where I could cry. I went somewhere where I could scream. I may have been alone, but in my own way, I locked the doors of my heart and my life in that moment, too. I vowed never to let somebody or something into my life in that way again. No, it was the road of doubt from here on out. I was going to check things twice before I signed on the dotted line again. “Measure twice, cut once,” my dad always said. There’s something in that. I was going to make sure I was never going to get caught like that again. 

I don’t know, but after a week of hanging out by myself and trying to put this all together, I decided to come back to the Upper Room. I’m not exactly sure why. I guess sometimes, even when you’re the most stubborn, you just need to be around people who have been through the same thing you have. You don’t even have to talk about what has just happened because you all understand that the silence is going to be okay. At least that’s what I hoped for. That’s what I expected when I got there. 

But they told me this incredible story. They said that he was back, that he had risen, that he had come and was among them—that the story wasn’t over. Now I know what you’re thinking, because I know how you’ve probably always heard the story. You say, “That’s when Thomas began to doubt. This resurrection business, he didn’t believe in that.” Well, I’ll tell you, I followed this guy. I knew that it was possible. I mean, I had seen what he had done for Lazarus, so it wasn’t out of the question. 

But I’ll tell you what gave me the doubt. They said he was back and he was showing his wounds. He was showing his scars. He was baring his shame, his woundedness, his brokenness, his incompleteness. I said, “I doubt it. I doubt it.” I mean, I saw what they did to him. I saw how they laughed at him. I saw how they made fun of him. Why on earth would he come back with those marks for everyone to see? I said, “I won’t believe that until I see it. I won’t believe that until I touch it.” The resurrection was possible, but to come back imperfect? Not my Savior. Not my Lord. Not with wounds. I didn’t need a wounded savior. 

And then suddenly, there he was, right in front of me. And there he stood, hands open, wounds visible, with the wound in his side. And he said, “Thomas, touch it. Feel it.” And I did. And there was a healing presence in his wounded touch that told me he had been to the places I had been in my life, that he indeed knew what it meant to hurt, he indeed knew what it meant to be in pain. And on that day, I touched the Wounded Healer and I learned that through his own wounds, he would bring healing to my life, and that maybe, just maybe, my own wounds, my own brokenness, my own shame might be able to bring healing to somebody else. 

There’s only one piece of advice I’d give to anybody who has been to the Upper Room. When you get a chance to touch the Wounded Healer, don’t just touch him, hold onto Jesus. During his loving and wounded embrace, there is wholeness and healing for you and for our world. This Easter, hold onto Jesus. Amen. 

* * * * *

 Reflection

Well, we’ve made it. Easter. If you’ve been with us at Sunday Night Alive the last few weeks of Lent, you know it’s been a journey. We’ve been talking a lot about the journey from brokenness to wholeness, trusting that in the same way, if we were to walk this journey together, if we were to remember the stories and to find ourselves in the stories, then maybe we would be able to find healing and wholeness for those places in our lives and in our world that often hurt or are often wounded. So here we are. Easter night. I’ll share a few reflections from the Upper Room, to send us from this journey to the next. 

The first thing to remember from our story tonight is that when the disciples went to the Upper Room, they locked the door. They locked it tight. Yes, it was because it was a dangerous time. But it was also a time when they were ashamed. They had really put all their hopes in this thing and it had fallen apart. Embarrassment, shame, hurt, brokenness—it’s pretty natural to want to lock that out. Or lock yourself in so you don’t have to share it with other people. 

We live in a society that really wants to suffer privately. And while confidentiality and privacy do have their place, we would be reminded that the first thing that happens, one of the first barriers that the resurrected Jesus transcends, is locked doors. It’s into the midst of that locked-out situation that the healing presence of Jesus appears, reminding all of us that it’s okay to be honest, it’s okay to allow ourselves and others to know the places that we have been, the struggles we have had, and the hurts we have endured. May we find that same healing presence entering into the locked places of our lives in the next journey to come. 

If you were with us a few weeks ago, you know that we talked about our own individual brokenness. And on that night, everybody was given a piece of glass. We talked about how each of those broken pieces represented our lives—different shapes, different colors, broken in different ways. And yet the one thing that made every piece of that glass the same was that it was broken. And we talked about what might happen if we were to bring our brokenness to the cross, to Jesus’ wide open arms. And tonight we can see what can happen when a broken people come together in the loving embrace of the Spirit of God—that God can take each of our lives in all of our brokenness, and begin to put them together into something beautiful. The church is lots of things, but one thing it can be is a beautiful mosaic of broken people who are committed to walking the journey of healing and wholeness together. 

We shouldn’t forget that it is on the arms of the one who was broken on the cross that we are allowed to come together into a place of healing. Jesus showed us that through our brokenness, our wholeness is actually a possibility. Just think of the places of hurt and brokenness in your life. Because of what you have been through and the ways that God has used you or brought you through it, what a gift you could be to somebody else who’s traveling down a similar road. Just think of the pain that you may have had as you struggled with the issues of unemployment and job loss. 

Just think about the healing presence you can be to somebody else who’s walking that journey. Maybe you’ve journeyed yourself or with a loved one through painful situations of addiction or depression or sickness or cancer. Think about how God can use the hurt that you felt or the experience that you’ve had with accompanying someone close to you through those difficult times. How you can use those wounded areas of your life to bring transformation to somebody else’s? It’s on the cross that our brokenness comes together into something far more beautiful than we could ever imagine. 

And if you’ve been journeying with us these last weeks, you have seen each week, piece by piece, we have put this pot back together. This pot symbolized our lives on this journey: broken. At each step of the way, we looked at how God could put the broken pieces of our lives back together. And here tonight, on Easter, in the full celebration of the resurrection promise, we can see that our lives and our communities can be made whole. And yet, like the resurrected Jesus, our wholeness still has its cracks, still has the marks of its woundedness. We don’t have to be afraid to be a bunch of cracked pots. Maybe that’s the story of Easter, because Jesus allowed the cracks and wounds of his life to be the place of transformation for those doubters who could once again become believers. 

One last story. There once was a man whose job was to bring water from a faraway well back to the house each day. He had one of those long poles, and on it he had two pots—one that he carried on each side of that stick. One pot was a whole pot, with no cracks in it. The other was a lot like our pot. It had cracks. And sure enough, just as you can imagine, the pot that was whole and seemed to have no blemish was able to do all it could do. It was able to bring a full pot of water back to the home each and every day. But the other pot, because of its cracks, couldn’t do the same thing that the whole pot could do. And each day when it got back to the house, half of the water would be gone. 

One day, the pot spoke to the man who was carrying it. It said: “I’m sorry. I’m sorry that through my cracks, I cannot do the whole job.” It was then that the water-bearer said to the cracked pot, “Come, let us walk the journey to the river once again today.” And as they walked, along the left hand side of the path, the side where the cracked pot had always been, the pot noticed something he had never noticed before. On that side of the path, and on that side of the path alone, there were grass and flowers. Each and every day for those two years where that man walked back and forth, that cracked pot watered the path. And unbeknownst to the cracked pot, his cracks became a symbol of beauty in the rest of the world. 

May that be a reminder to all of us on this, our Easter journey, that the cracks in our lives can actually bring healing and beauty to the world when it is the love of God and the grace of Christ that is poured into our lives and then poured out to others.


 


The Cross and Flame is a registered trademark of The United Methodist Church.®
Copyright 1998-2008. First United Methodist Church.
1589 West Maple Road, Birmingham, Michigan 48009 U.S.A.
248-646-1200.

Map and Contact Information

Contact Us | Calendar of Events | Sermon Archive | Announcements | Steeple Notes (newsletter) | Mission and Outreach | Music | Prayer and Healing | Christian Education | Christian Life Center | Adults | Youth | Children and Families | About Us | Virtual Bookstore | Online Donations | Monday Memo |